Starfish Space has lost contact with its Otter 24C spacecraft, prematurely ending a $15 million NASA in-space inspection mission just one month after launch. The failure marks the second on-orbit mishap for the company in recent years, both attributed to third-party hardware issues.
What Happened
Otter 24C launched on Oct. 1 as part of SpaceX’s Transporter-18 rideshare mission and initially established contact with ground control shortly after deployment. The spacecraft was tasked with the Small Spacecraft Propulsion and Inspection Capability (SSPICy) mission, which aimed to approach and inspect multiple defunct US satellites to gather data for future potential deorbit operations.
During the satellite’s commissioning phase, an error occurred in the fault protection system of Otter’s bus, provided by Astro Digital. This glitch caused the onboard radio to turn off, resulting in a communications blackout. Starfish was unable to reestablish contact, rendering the spacecraft unrecoverable. While NASA and Starfish are exploring whether remaining objectives can be completed via other Starfish missions, Otter 24C itself is considered lost.
Why It Matters
The loss of Otter 24C cuts short NASA’s first funded foray into commercial debris inspection missions, representing a significant setback for the agency's In-Space Servicing, Assembly, and Manufacturing (ISAM) efforts. This incident follows a recent failure in a NASA mission with Katalyst Space, which failed to boost the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory, marking back-to-back disappointments for commercial ISAM initiatives.
For Starfish, this is the second major on-orbit failure linked to third-party hardware. In 2023, the company’s first satellite, Otter Pup 1, was deployed into a tumble after an anomaly with its launch provider, Launcher. Engineers successfully reversed the spin after six weeks, but the current radio failure proved fatal to the mission. Despite these setbacks, Starfish continues to demonstrate operational capability; its Otter Pup 2 spacecraft, launched in 2025, recently maneuvered to within 33 meters of Gilmour Space’s ElaraSat, showcasing proximity operations skills.
The company remains a key partner for US government contracts, having been awarded a $52.5 million deal by the Space Development Agency (SDA) in January to deorbit satellites as part of the Proliferated Warfighter Space Architecture. Starfish stated it is implementing fixes to the Astro Digital bus to prevent similar failure modes in future missions.
The Bottom Line
Otter 24C is unrecoverable after a radio failure caused by a fault protection error on its Astro Digital bus. While the $15M NASA SSPICY mission ends early, Starfish aims to complete remaining objectives on future flights and continues to hold significant government contracts for debris removal.