The number of launches SpaceX’s Starship will need to land astronauts on the moon remains uncertain, with estimates ranging from a Government Accountability Office figure of up to 16 to a recent Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel suggestion of 22. SpaceX CEO Elon Musk has countered with a lower estimate of six to eight flights, highlighting the ongoing ambiguity surrounding the Artemis IV mission architecture.

What Happened

NASA recently released a graphic detailing the order of operations for Artemis IV, the program’s first crewed lunar landing under the current Starship lander plan. The mission begins with a Space Launch System (SLS) rocket launching four astronauts in an Orion capsule to high Earth orbit. However, Starship’s refueling process occurs in a staggered sequence before the astronauts arrive in orbit.

According to the NASA outline, SpaceX will first launch a depot ship to low Earth orbit (LEO). Multiple tanker Starships will dock with this depot to fill it with propellant. Once the depot is filled, the Starship lunar lander will launch to LEO and dock with the depot for an initial fuel transfer. The lander will then undock and raise its altitude to what NASA labels the 'final tanking orbit' (FTO).

After the lander departs LEO, SpaceX will launch another round of tanker ships to refill the depot. The depot will then travel to the FTO to meet the lander for a final fuel transfer. Following this second docking, the Starship lander will ascend to high Earth orbit to rendezvous with the Orion capsule, which will have been launched by SLS in the interim. This choreography is designed to provide flexibility regarding the SLS launch timing.

Why It Matters

The complexity of the refueling plan and the discrepancy in flight count estimates underscore the technical risks inherent in the Artemis IV mission. NASA states that this staggered orbital staging will actually reduce the total amount of fuel SpaceX needs for the mission, partly because Starship will deliver Orion directly to low lunar orbit rather than a higher orbit used in previous plans. However, the reliance on multiple tanker flights and a depot ship introduces significant logistical hurdles.

The uncertainty also impacts the competitive landscape for NASA’s lander contracts. If SpaceX cannot demonstrate its orbital refueling strategy or complete an uncrewed lunar landing mission by the end of next year, NASA could select Blue Origin’s Blue Moon lander for Artemis IV, provided Blue Origin meets its required milestones. The final mission architecture will likely remain in flux until closer to the launch date.

The Bottom Line

SpaceX’s plan to use Starship as the Artemis IV lander involves a complex, multi-stage refueling process with estimates for the number of necessary launches varying widely between officials and the company. While NASA argues the new orbital staging reduces fuel requirements, the plan remains contingent on successful demonstration of orbital refueling and uncrewed lunar landings, with Blue Origin’s Blue Moon standing by as a potential alternative.