Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile are petitioning the Federal Communications Commission to exclude nearly 300 MHz of spectrum from a rulemaking proposal that would expand direct-to-device satellite services. The request arrives just one day before the agency is scheduled to vote on the notice of proposed rulemaking.

What Happened

The FCC is set to vote on Thursday, October 29, on a proposal to make an additional 482 MHz of spectrum available for direct-to-device services, increasing the number of eligible bands from five to 13. The proposal would also eliminate the requirement for satellite operators to lease spectrum from terrestrial carriers, replacing it with a certification that coexistence agreements are in place or that the operator holds the terrestrial license itself.

Through the industry group CTIA, the three major carriers argued that approximately 300 million users rely on the 2.5 GHz and 3.45 GHz bands, which constitute 290 MHz of the spectrum under consideration. They contended that satellite operations in these bands are not technically feasible. In a separate filing, T-Mobile stated that satellite interference could eliminate up to 96% of a cell site’s uplink coverage area and reduce uplink speeds by 88% to 99%.

Executives from the carriers met with FCC staff on October 20, and T-Mobile CEO Srini Gopalan met separately with FCC Chairman Brendan Carr. Meanwhile, SpaceX filed a document on October 23 requesting the addition of the 902 to 928 MHz band to the proposal, arguing that including it now would save time later. SpaceX also urged the FCC to modernize interference rules and align satellite deployment requirements with terrestrial network standards to ensure connectivity across both systems.

Why It Matters

The proposed rule change is significant for SpaceX’s strategy to become a full US carrier, a move supported by its recent agreement to purchase Grain Management’s nationwide 800 MHz portfolio. This acquisition builds on spectrum SpaceX previously bought from EchoStar to support Starlink Mobile. However, the competitive dynamics are complex: T-Mobile remains SpaceX’s US launch partner for Starlink Mobile, yet the three major carriers have formed their own satellite joint venture to pool spectrum, a move widely viewed as a response to Starlink’s growth.

Industry perspectives on the competition vary. Verizon CEO noted during a third-quarter earnings call that Starlink Mobile “just can’t compete with a terrestrial network,” estimating that SpaceX would need four to six years and between $300 billion and $500 billion to build a comparable full US carrier network. The FCC has previously considered and rejected the use of the 2.5 GHz band for satellite coverage in 2024, highlighting the contentious nature of this spectrum allocation.

The Bottom Line

Thursday’s vote will not finalize which bands are included, as adopting the notice opens a public comment period with final rules expected later in the proceeding. The regulatory landscape is shifting for other players as well; the FCC approved Amazon’s $11.6 billion acquisition of Globalstar on October 27, granting its planned direct-to-device fleet its own mobile satellite spectrum.